{
  "name": "CSAF Publisher Practice 2026: what published CSAF documents say and how they identify products",
  "description": "Aggregate measurement of 12,813 CSAF 2.0 documents changed between 22 November 2024 and 22 November 2026 by the 38 providers listed by the BSI CSAF lister and the CERT@VDE CSAF aggregator, with Red Hat and Huawei left out. For each source type it counts how often a document states that a product is not affected, names a fixed version or a vendor fix, and how each product is identified: CPE, model number, Package URL (purl), SKU or name only. Results are per source type, never per vendor.",
  "url": "https://cradata.eu/csaf-publisher-practice",
  "publisher": "CVD Portal, Porta Regulus B.V.",
  "license": "CC BY 4.0",
  "licenseUrl": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/",
  "scannedAt": "2026-11-22",
  "lastVerified": "2026-11-22",
  "citation": "CVD Portal, \"CSAF Publisher Practice 2026: what published CSAF documents say and how they identify products\", 2026-11-22. https://cradata.eu/csaf-publisher-practice (CC BY 4.0)",
  "methodology": {
    "kind": "Measurement study of public CSAF 2.0 documents. Aggregates only.",
    "providerLists": [
      {
        "label": "BSI CSAF lister",
        "url": "https://wid.cert-bund.de/.well-known/csaf-aggregator/aggregator.json",
        "providers": 14
      },
      {
        "label": "CERT@VDE CSAF aggregator",
        "url": "https://aggregator.certvde.com/.well-known/csaf-aggregator/aggregator.json",
        "providers": 26
      }
    ],
    "excluded": [
      {
        "publisher": "Red Hat Product Security",
        "reason": "Publishes one VEX document per CVE for operating system packages, tens of thousands of files, which would outweigh every other provider."
      },
      {
        "publisher": "Huawei PSIRT",
        "reason": "Left out with Red Hat to keep the download bounded. It is a consumer and telecom vendor, outside the industrial focus of the CERT@VDE list."
      }
    ],
    "timeWindow": "Documents changed in the two years before the run, 2024-11-22 to 2026-11-22, by the date in each provider's changes.csv or ROLIE feed (csaf_downloader -t 2y).",
    "tool": "csaf_downloader from the gocsaf project, which checks each document against the CSAF JSON schema and its hash before it stores the file.",
    "sourceTypes": {
      "vendor_psirt": "A manufacturer or software vendor that publishes CSAF about its own products. 36 publishers.",
      "bsi_wid": "The BSI Warn- und Informationsdienst. It republishes advisories about third-party products, mostly as csaf_base documents with no product status.",
      "cisa": "CISA industrial control system advisories about third-party products."
    },
    "definitions": {
      "documentsWithKnownNotAffected": "Documents with at least one product in /vulnerabilities[]/product_status/known_not_affected.",
      "documentsWithFixedStatus": "Documents with at least one product in product_status fixed or first_fixed.",
      "documentsWithVendorFixRemediation": "Documents with at least one remediation of category vendor_fix.",
      "productsWithAnyIdentifier": "Products in the product tree whose product_identification_helper carries a CPE, model number, purl, SKU, hash, serial number, SBOM URL or generic URI. The rest are identified by name only.",
      "products": "Products defined in the product tree branches and in full_product_names. All product and identifier percentages use this count.",
      "relationshipProducts": "Products that a relationship defines by combining two other products, for example firmware installed on a device. They are counted apart, because each one is built from two products that the main count already holds, and a matching tool can use the identifiers of those two products."
    },
    "script": "https://github.com/porta-regulus/cvdportal/blob/main/scripts/research/csaf-publisher-practice.py",
    "limits": [
      "Two years of documents only. Older advisories are not counted.",
      "A document counts once, at its current version.",
      "A product that appears in several documents counts once per document.",
      "The study measures what the documents say. It does not check whether a statement is correct.",
      "BSI and CISA documents describe other parties' products, so their figures measure the intermediary, not the vendor."
    ]
  },
  "summary": {
    "documents": 12813,
    "providersListed": 40,
    "providersMeasured": 38,
    "vendorPsirtDocuments": 907,
    "vendorPsirtPublishers": 36,
    "vendorPsirtDocumentsWithKnownNotAffectedPct": 7.4,
    "vendorPsirtDocumentsWithVendorFixRemediationPct": 84.5,
    "vendorPsirtProductsNameOnlyPct": 43.0,
    "vendorPsirtProductsWithModelNumberPct": 43.9,
    "vendorPsirtProductsWithCpePct": 6.0,
    "vendorPsirtProductsWithPurlPct": 8.7,
    "vendorPsirtRelationshipProducts": 8131,
    "vendorPsirtRelationshipProductsWithOwnIdentifierPct": 27.5
  },
  "bySourceType": {
    "all": {
      "documents": 12813,
      "publishers": 38,
      "documentsByCategory": {
        "csaf_base": 9883,
        "csaf_security_advisory": 2749,
        "csaf_vex": 181
      },
      "documentsWithKnownNotAffected": 97,
      "documentsWithKnownNotAffectedPct": 0.8,
      "documentsWithFixedStatus": 743,
      "documentsWithFixedStatusPct": 5.8,
      "documentsWithVendorFixRemediation": 1780,
      "documentsWithVendorFixRemediationPct": 13.9,
      "products": 126504,
      "productsWithAnyIdentifier": 79829,
      "productsWithAnyIdentifierPct": 63.1,
      "productsNameOnlyPct": 36.9,
      "productsWithIdentifierPct": {
        "cpe": 51.8,
        "model_numbers": 10.4,
        "purl": 1.0,
        "skus": 0.1,
        "hashes": 0.0,
        "serial_numbers": 0.0,
        "x_generic_uris": 0.3,
        "sbom_urls": 0.0
      },
      "productStatusEntries": {
        "first_affected": 4,
        "first_fixed": 76,
        "fixed": 14042,
        "known_affected": 901010,
        "known_not_affected": 6076,
        "last_affected": 8840,
        "recommended": 161,
        "under_investigation": 198
      },
      "relationshipProducts": 9891,
      "relationshipProductsWithOwnIdentifierPct": 23.3
    },
    "vendor_psirt": {
      "documents": 907,
      "publishers": 36,
      "documentsByCategory": {
        "csaf_security_advisory": 835,
        "csaf_vex": 72
      },
      "documentsWithKnownNotAffected": 67,
      "documentsWithKnownNotAffectedPct": 7.4,
      "documentsWithFixedStatus": 534,
      "documentsWithFixedStatusPct": 58.9,
      "documentsWithVendorFixRemediation": 766,
      "documentsWithVendorFixRemediationPct": 84.5,
      "products": 14956,
      "productsWithAnyIdentifier": 8518,
      "productsWithAnyIdentifierPct": 57.0,
      "productsNameOnlyPct": 43.0,
      "productsWithIdentifierPct": {
        "cpe": 6.0,
        "model_numbers": 43.9,
        "purl": 8.7,
        "skus": 0.9,
        "hashes": 0.1,
        "serial_numbers": 0.2,
        "x_generic_uris": 1.9,
        "sbom_urls": 0.0
      },
      "productStatusEntries": {
        "first_affected": 4,
        "first_fixed": 76,
        "fixed": 11523,
        "known_affected": 41727,
        "known_not_affected": 3799,
        "last_affected": 435,
        "recommended": 121,
        "under_investigation": 198
      },
      "relationshipProducts": 8131,
      "relationshipProductsWithOwnIdentifierPct": 27.5
    },
    "bsi_wid": {
      "documents": 9885,
      "publishers": 1,
      "documentsByCategory": {
        "csaf_base": 9883,
        "csaf_security_advisory": 2
      },
      "documentsWithKnownNotAffected": 2,
      "documentsWithKnownNotAffectedPct": 0.0,
      "documentsWithFixedStatus": 2,
      "documentsWithFixedStatusPct": 0.0,
      "documentsWithVendorFixRemediation": 2,
      "documentsWithVendorFixRemediationPct": 0.0,
      "products": 92840,
      "productsWithAnyIdentifier": 64614,
      "productsWithAnyIdentifierPct": 69.6,
      "productsNameOnlyPct": 30.4,
      "productsWithIdentifierPct": {
        "cpe": 69.5,
        "model_numbers": 0.0,
        "purl": 0.0,
        "skus": 0.0,
        "hashes": 0.0,
        "serial_numbers": 0.0,
        "x_generic_uris": 0.0,
        "sbom_urls": 0.0
      },
      "productStatusEntries": {
        "fixed": 449,
        "known_affected": 812892,
        "known_not_affected": 331,
        "last_affected": 8405,
        "recommended": 33
      },
      "relationshipProducts": 1325,
      "relationshipProductsWithOwnIdentifierPct": 0.0
    },
    "cisa": {
      "documents": 2021,
      "publishers": 1,
      "documentsByCategory": {
        "csaf_security_advisory": 1912,
        "csaf_vex": 109
      },
      "documentsWithKnownNotAffected": 28,
      "documentsWithKnownNotAffectedPct": 1.4,
      "documentsWithFixedStatus": 207,
      "documentsWithFixedStatusPct": 10.2,
      "documentsWithVendorFixRemediation": 1012,
      "documentsWithVendorFixRemediationPct": 50.1,
      "products": 18708,
      "productsWithAnyIdentifier": 6697,
      "productsWithAnyIdentifierPct": 35.8,
      "productsNameOnlyPct": 64.2,
      "productsWithIdentifierPct": {
        "cpe": 0.1,
        "model_numbers": 35.5,
        "purl": 0.0,
        "skus": 0.1,
        "hashes": 0.0,
        "serial_numbers": 0.0,
        "x_generic_uris": 0.5,
        "sbom_urls": 0.0
      },
      "productStatusEntries": {
        "fixed": 2070,
        "known_affected": 46391,
        "known_not_affected": 1946,
        "recommended": 7
      },
      "relationshipProducts": 435,
      "relationshipProductsWithOwnIdentifierPct": 15.6
    }
  }
}
